CnC Foren

CnC Foren (http://www.cncforen.de/index.php)
-   Tiberium Wars (C&C3) (http://www.cncforen.de/forumdisplay.php?f=496)
-   -   C&C3 TW DVD Covercontest - Das Voting (http://www.cncforen.de/showthread.php?t=69624)

feuerreal 22-11-2006 23:53
C&C3 TW DVD Covercontest - Das Voting
 
Um die Übersichtlichkeit zu wahren und letztendlich ein objektives Ergebnis zu erhalten hab ich mir mal erlaubt nen komplett neuen Thread zu öffnen.
Nun ist auch die Reihenfolge der Cover identisch mit dem UF.


Ich würde Mal vorschlagen, dass wir es wie auf dem UF machen.
Sonst kommen wir zu keinem halbwegs objektivem Ergebnis.

ACHTUNG: Nur 1x voten. Also nicht hier, auf dem UF und auf der Page voten.

Jeder kann Punkte von 1 bis 10 vergeben.
Daher sollte jeder nach folgendem Schema antworten:


____________________________________________________
Übersicht:

http://img490.imageshack.us/img490/2769/1jo9.jpg
Cover 1 __ Cover 2 __ Cover 3 __ Cover 4 __ Cover 5

http://img97.imageshack.us/img97/3872/2sj2.jpg
Cover 6 __ Cover 7 __ Cover 8 ____ Cover 9 _____ Cover 10

http://img89.imageshack.us/img89/8373/3kf5.jpg
Cover 11 __ Cover 12 ___ Cover 13 ____ Cover 14

http://img471.imageshack.us/img471/9366/4kg5.jpg
Cover 15 ___ Cover 16 ___ Cover 17
_______________________________________________
Antwortschema:

Cover 01 =
Cover 02 =
Cover 03 =
Cover 04 =
Cover 05 =
Cover 06 =
Cover 07 =
Cover 08 =
Cover 09 =
Cover 10 =
Cover 11 =
Cover 12 =
Cover 13 =
Cover 14 =
Cover 15 =
Cover 16 =
Cover 17 =
_______________________________________________


Greetz Grey

_______________________________________________

Zwischenstand:Gewertet bis Post #19




















Cover-Nr. Alle Punkte Ø
Cover 01 : 55 3,235
Cover 02 : 77 4,529
Cover 03 : 57 3,353
Cover 04 : 39 2,294
Cover 05 : 102 6,000
Cover 06 : 87 5,118
Cover 07 : 82 4,824
Cover 08 : 70 4,118
Cover 09 : 61 3,588
Cover 10 : 80 4,706
Cover 11 : 132 7,765
Cover 12 : 91 5,353
Cover 13 : 119 7,000
Cover 14 : 51 3,000
Cover 15 : 155 9,118
Cover 16 : 43 2,529
Cover 17 : 65 3,824


NavcomTCommando 23-11-2006 00:26
Cover 01 = 2
Cover 02 = 5
Cover 03 = 1
Cover 04 = 6
Cover 05 = 5
Cover 06 = 7
Cover 07 = 1
Cover 08 = 1
Cover 09 = 4
Cover 10 = 5
Cover 11 = 8
Cover 12 = 1
Cover 13 = 7
Cover 14 = 1
Cover 15 = 10
Cover 16 = 2
Cover 17 = 3

Bubba 23-11-2006 13:32
Sollen wir jetzt eigentlich nur das Konzept oder auch die Grafik bewerten?
Letzteres würde fürs fertige Produkt ja sowieso nochmal professionell überarbeitet werden.

Cover 01 = 3
Cover 02 = 4
Cover 03 = 6
Cover 04 = 2
Cover 05 = 9
Cover 06 = 5
Cover 07 = 8
Cover 08 = 7
Cover 09 = 3
Cover 10 = 5
Cover 11 = 6
Cover 12 = 7
Cover 13 = 6
Cover 14 = 3
Cover 15 = 10
Cover 16 = 1
Cover 17 = 5

Saroc 23-11-2006 13:43
Cover 01 = 1
Cover 02 = 3
Cover 03 = 3
Cover 04 = 1
Cover 05 = 9
Cover 06 = 4
Cover 07 = 4
Cover 08 = 3
Cover 09 = 3
Cover 10 = 6
Cover 11 = 8
Cover 12 = 10
Cover 13 = 7
Cover 14 = 2
Cover 15 = 8
Cover 16 = 1
Cover 17 = 2

feuerreal 23-11-2006 16:01
Cover 01 = 2
Cover 02 = 3
Cover 03 = 3
Cover 04 = 1
Cover 05 = 2
Cover 06 = 5
Cover 07 = 7
Cover 08 = 8
Cover 09 = 4
Cover 10 = 4
Cover 11 = 8
Cover 12 = 8
Cover 13 = 9
Cover 14 = 4
Cover 15 = 10
Cover 16 = 3
Cover 17 = 6


Greetz Grey

RedBasti 23-11-2006 16:45
Cover 01 =3
Cover 02 =6
Cover 03 =6
Cover 04 =1
Cover 05 =4
Cover 06 =7
Cover 07 =6
Cover 08 =5
Cover 09 =5
Cover 10 =7
Cover 11 =9
Cover 12 =8
Cover 13 =9
Cover 14 =4
Cover 15 =10
Cover 16 =4
Cover 17 =4

nettesau 23-11-2006 17:35
Cover 01 =1
Cover 02 =3
Cover 03 =2
Cover 04 =8
Cover 05 =2
Cover 06 =2
Cover 07 =1
Cover 08 =1
Cover 09 =4
Cover 10 =4
Cover 11 =7
Cover 12 =1
Cover 13 =4
Cover 14 =4
Cover 15 =10
Cover 16 =1
Cover 17 =1

Narodnaja 23-11-2006 21:25
Cover 01 = 3
Cover 02 = 4
Cover 03 = 5
Cover 04 = 7
Cover 05 = 5
Cover 06 = 6
Cover 07 = 7
Cover 08 = 7
Cover 09 = 5
Cover 10 = 4
Cover 11 = 7
Cover 12 = 8
Cover 13 = 6
Cover 14 = 4
Cover 15 = 10
Cover 16 = 4
Cover 17 = 5

EEBKiller 23-11-2006 22:16
Cover 01 = 3
Cover 02 = 2
Cover 03 = 1
Cover 04 = 1
Cover 05 = 3
Cover 06 = 5
Cover 07 = 6
Cover 08 = 5
Cover 09 = 1
Cover 10 = 2
Cover 11 = 7
Cover 12 = 6
Cover 13 = 8
Cover 14 = 4
Cover 15 = 10
Cover 16 = 1
Cover 17 = 2

Chrissyx 23-11-2006 23:20
Dann will ich auch mal:

Cover 01 = 2
Cover 02 = 3
Cover 03 = 1
Cover 04 = 1
Cover 05 = 10
Cover 06 = 3
Cover 07 = 3
Cover 08 = 4
Cover 09 = 1
Cover 10 = 3
Cover 11 = 8
Cover 12 = 3
Cover 13 = 9
Cover 14 = 2
Cover 15 = 10
Cover 16 = 1
Cover 17 = 2

15 ist definitiv das Beste, dicht gefolgt von 13 und 11. Die 5 steht ausser Konkurrenz - goldenes Logo rulez! :gf:

EDIT: Vielleicht sollte ich auch noch zur 5 sagen, dass hier der Ansatz "Gesicht mit Brille, in der sich Action spiegelt" ebenfalls verfolgt wurde. Die grafische Umsetzung ist sicher nicht die Beste, aber allein für diese Kontinuität gibt's volle Punkte. Sogar 11 wenn's möglich wäre. Die 15 hat diese Aspekte zwar weniger bzw. gar nicht, gleicht es aber durch Nennung der Vorgängertitel (sogar mit korrekten Namen!), Speigelung der Scrin-Primal Szene von Tiberian Twilight im Visier (!) und die absolut perfekte Gestaltung wieder aus und bekommt so auch verdient 10 Punkte.

Amosh 23-11-2006 23:56
Cover 01 = 3
Cover 02 = 6
Cover 03 = 4
Cover 04 = 1
Cover 05 = 8
Cover 06 = 7
Cover 07 = 2
Cover 08 = 2
Cover 09 = 1
Cover 10 = 8
Cover 11 = 10
Cover 12 = 5
Cover 13 = 9
Cover 14 = 4
Cover 15 = 10
Cover 16 = 4
Cover 17 = 6

Ich muss sagen, dass Nr 15 und Nr. 11 mit Abstand die besten sind, gefolgt von Nr 13. Nr. 4 ist außer Konkurrenz. ^^

LordMordred 24-11-2006 10:20
Cover 01 =3
Cover 02 =6
Cover 03 =4
Cover 04 =1
Cover 05 =4
Cover 06 =5
Cover 07 =5
Cover 08 =4
Cover 09 =1+3=4
Cover 10 =4+3=7
Cover 11 =5+3=8
Cover 12 =4
Cover 13 =5+3=8
Cover 14 =3+3=6
Cover 15 =6+3=9
Cover 16 =2+3=5
Cover 17 =4+3=7

PS: bei 15 fehlte mir eigentlich nur das richtige Logo, dadurch -1, den einen Punkt hat aber auch nur einer bekommen.

Müller 24-11-2006 12:29
Cover 01 = 2
Cover 02 = 4
Cover 03 = 4
Cover 04 = 1
Cover 05 = 2
Cover 06 = 4
Cover 07 = 6
Cover 08 = 3
Cover 09 = 4
Cover 10 = 3
Cover 11 = 9
Cover 12 = 8
Cover 13 = 8
Cover 14 = 2
Cover 15 = 10
Cover 16 = 2
Cover 17 = 3

Kroko 24-11-2006 15:36
Cover 01 = 10
Cover 02 = 7
Cover 03 = 8
Cover 04 =4
Cover 05 = 10
Cover 06 = 9
Cover 07 = 6
Cover 08 =1
Cover 09 = 8
Cover 10 =6
Cover 11 = 9
Cover 12 =5
Cover 13 =3
Cover 14 =1
Cover 15 =3
Cover 16 =2
Cover 17 = 7

MRThomm 24-11-2006 17:59
Cover 01 = 3
Cover 02 = 7
Cover 03 = 2
Cover 04 = 1
Cover 05 = 4
Cover 06 = 4
Cover 07 = 2
Cover 08 = 2
Cover 09 = 4
Cover 10 = 7
Cover 11 = 9
Cover 12 = 4
Cover 13 = 8
Cover 14 = 5
Cover 15 = 10
Cover 16 = 4
Cover 17 = 5

Rakzer0 24-11-2006 22:12
Cover 01 = 5
Cover 02 = 3
Cover 03 = 2
Cover 04 = 1
Cover 05 = 10
Cover 06 = 3
Cover 07 = 1
Cover 08 = 1
Cover 09 = 2
Cover 10 = 2
Cover 11 = 2
Cover 12 = 1
Cover 13 = 3
Cover 14 = 2
Cover 15 = 6
Cover 16 = 2
Cover 17 = 2

Cleaner05 25-11-2006 13:22
Cover 01 =1
Cover 02 =3
Cover 03 =2
Cover 04 =8
Cover 05 =2
Cover 06 =2
Cover 07 =1
Cover 08 =1
Cover 09 =4
Cover 10 =4
Cover 11 =7
Cover 12 =1
Cover 13 =4
Cover 14 =4
Cover 15 =10
Cover 16 =1
Cover 17 =1

der-bettler 27-11-2006 00:52
Cover 01 = 6
Cover 02 = 6
Cover 03 = 3
Cover 04 = 0
Cover 05 = 7
Cover 06 = 7
Cover 07 = 9
Cover 08 = 9
Cover 09 = 5
Cover 10 = 2
Cover 11 = 9
Cover 12 = 7
Cover 13 = 8
Cover 14 = 1
Cover 15 = 10
Cover 16 =0
Cover 17 =1

Tigershark 28-11-2006 00:42
Cover 01 =3
Cover 02 =5
Cover 03 =2
Cover 04 =1
Cover 05 =8
Cover 06 =4
Cover 07 =8
Cover 08 =7
Cover 09 =3
Cover 10 =5
Cover 11 =8
Cover 12 =5
Cover 13 =7
Cover 14 =2
Cover 15 =9
Cover 16 =5
Cover 17 =4

LordMordred 04-12-2006 09:57
______________________________________________________________
:lock:



















Wertung
CnCForen 		Cover-Nr. Alle Punkte Ø
1. Cover 15 : 155 9,118
2. Cover 11 : 132 7,765
3. Cover 13 : 119 7,000
4. Cover 05 : 102 6,000
5. Cover 12 : 91 5,353
6. Cover 06 : 87 5,118
7. Cover 07 : 82 4,824
8. Cover 10 : 80 4,706
9. Cover 02 : 77 4,529
10. Cover 08 : 70 4,118
11. Cover 17 : 65 3,824
12. Cover 09 : 61 3,588
13. Cover 03 : 57 3,353
14. Cover 01 : 55 3,235
15. Cover 14 : 51 3,000
16. Cover 16 : 43 2,529
17. Cover 04 : 39 2,294


Alle Zeitangaben in WEZ +2. Es ist jetzt 21:42 Uhr.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.7.3 (Deutsch)
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.